Refugees

25/07/2022

I was little when I heard my parents talking about their experiences as political refugees. First in French camps, after the Spanish Civil War, then as asylees in the Soviet Union between late 1939 and early 1948. In elementary school, I was friends with Alex, the youngest son of Federico Melchior, the editor-in-chief of “Mundo Obrero.” Then, in highschol, with Charalambis, son of the editor of “Neos Kosmos.” Nansen passports. Like Menelaos Ludemis, like Dimos Rendis. LikeYannis Veakis, Elena Patrascanu’s secnd husband. I warmly recommend Apostolos Patelakis’s book about the Greek political refugees in Romania. Later, I read Koestler’s “Scum of the Earth” and Hannah Arendt’s essay “We, Refugees.” To be a political refugee means Heimatslosigkeit. Uprootedness. No civic rights. Unprotectedness. Defenselessness. Hopelessnes. Helplessness. Carola Neher was a political refugee in the USSR. So were Maria Osten, Eva Zeisel, Alex Weissberg, Margarete Buber Neumann. So were Elena Filipovici, Marcel Pauker (Luximin), David Fabian, and Alexandru Dobrogeanu-Gherea. No light at the end of the existential tunnel. A bureaucrat’s whim determines the refugee’s destiny. Transit. Like in Anna Seghers’s novel and Christian Petzold’s film. Like in Walter Benjamin’ failed attempt to escape France. Like in Danilo Kis’s “A Tomb for Boris Davidovich.”

Photo: Moscow, 1940, after the Spanish Civil War my parents were political refugees in the Soviet Union. She was 25, he was 27. The then general secretary of the Communist Party of Romania (Section of the Communist International), Boris Stefanov, urged them not to ask questions about prominent Romanian refugees. Silence was a rule of survival. In Moscow, my mother was on friendly terms with two German refugees: Helene (Lena) Berg and Hanna (Haschka) Wolf. They were close friends with Hilde Benjamin, WB’s sister-in-law and the GDR’s first Minister of Justice. Georg Benjamin died in a Nazi concentration camp. Hilde was a fanatic instrument of “class justice.” Lena served as SED representative on the editorial board of the Prague- based monthly “World Marxist Review.” Haschka was Rector of the SED’s Superior Party School. Both were CC members.


Ce este fascismul?

21/06/2022

În aceste săptămâni am revenit la lecturile mele despre fascism. Mi se pare esențial să demistificăm propaganda putinistă cât mai argumentat. “Nazismul” imaginar atribuit Ucrainei democratice este de fapt proiecția fascismului real ale bandei lui Putin. Voi reveni în zilele următoare la chestiuni ce privesc conceptul de totalitarism. Pentru moment, iată o formulare sintetică și succintă a naturii nazismului propusă de N. Steinhardt în 1946 într-o recenzie a romanului lui Lion Feuchtwanger “Falsul Nero”: “Esența național-socialismului e crima organizată pusă la dispoziția unei clici”. (“Articole burgheze”, Mănăstirea Rohia/Polirom, 2008, p. 377.)


“Restricted” pe FB

10/06/2022

Mesaj de la Vladimir Tismaneanu

“Your previous posts didn’t follow our Community Standards, so you can’t do things like post or comment.” Am făcut apel la Board-ul FB. Postarea era din 28 mai 2022. Este limpede ca cineva, “stim noi cine”, cauta in arhiva paginii mele orice poate genera asemenea stupide hartuieli. Am spus ca poza este de la Conferința de la Munchen din septembrie 1938, ca îi include pe premierii Neville Chamberlain si Edouard Daladier împreuna cu dictatorul german Adolf Hitler. Postarea era despre complicitati, ingenuncheri, capitulari. Despre appeasement.


What Charlottesville is about…

18/08/2017

I’m the last person to condone far left violence. I’m unequivocally opposed to any extra-legal forms of rebellion (I don’t regard totalitarian decrees, abusively and arbitrarily humiliating, as laws). I admire Thoreau, but I think that civil disobedience ought to be civilian (with bold characters), i.e., non violent, decent, civilized. I detest Molotov, in any of his incarnations: as the man who signed the infamous pact and as a “revolutionary” cocktail. My admiration for the whole civil society strategy that triumphed in Eastern Europe during the annus mirabilis 1989 is precisely rooted in this philosophical engagement. But I need to say it emphatically: Charlottesville is the name of far right (alt right, as it were) jingoism, racism, anti-Semitism, white resentment, lumpen malaise, in short updated, Americanized Fascism. I just read a great essay by Mary McCarthy titled “Hannah Arendt and Politics.” It reminded me that during Senator McCarthy’s vicious witchhunts, Hannah Arendt considered returning to Europe, becoming a refugee for the second time in her life. Neither she nor her husband were directly targeted, but they felt that America was running amok. For me, 45’s conduct is just latter day McCarthyism…


Alfabetul extremismului

15/05/2017

Caruselul ideilor, angajamentelor și patimilor politice în veacul XX este amețitor. Mai ales când vine vorba de radicalisme, de pasiuni, iluzii și minciuni, spre a relua titlul cărții postume a lui François Furet. Hitler ar fi spus că dintr-un comunist poate face un bun nazist, niciodată însă dintr-un social-democrat (apud Hermann Rauschning). Tot Hitler, imbătat cu propriile obsesii, spunea că isi urmează destinul cu certitudinea unui somambul. Salturile mortale de la o extremă la alta se explică tocmai prin similitudinea fanatismelor ce le motivează. Jacques Doriot (1898—1945), fascistul francez, lider al asa-zisului „Partid Popular Francez”, fusese membru al CC al PCF și deputatul circumscripției roșii, St Denis. Mussolini a pornit ca socialist radical, chiar internaționalist. A fost idolul tinerilor Antonio Gramsci și Palmiro Togliatti. In ale sale „Caiete din inchisoare”, Gramsci îsi amintea de vremurile când peripatetiza în compania lui Mussolini…

Ideologul fascist Nicola Bombacci a fost inițial comunist, dar a murit împușcat, în aprilie 1945, ca ideolog al odioasei Republici de la Salò, socialistă, fascistă și exterministă, înfrățit cu amicul său Benito, reîntors la fantasmele roșii ale juneții sale, sub patronaj nazist. Chiar A. C. Cuza, antisemit epidermic, era, în junețe, un fel de socialist. August Bebel a spus, și nu greșea, că antisemitismul e socialismul proștilor. Stalin l-a definit, în anii 30, drept canibalismul epocii noastre, doar că nu a ezitat să devină el însuși un canibal. In ultimii ani de viață, dictatorul sociopat lansa acuzații delirante la adresa medicilor evrei și pregătea deportarea în masă a evreilor, cei pe care propaganda oficială îi stigmatiza drept „cosmopoliți fără rădăcini”, spre viitoare lagăre de concentrare (în curs de pregătire). Denigrat de stânga, Friedrich Nietzsche a fost criticul cel mai virulent al antisemitismului. L-a disprețuit visceral. Îl considera vulgar, resentimentar, abject. Nu însă și contemporanul său, Karl Marx, cel care echivala, asemeni lui Richard Wagner, Banul cu Evreul, iudaismul cu capitalismul, cu sistemul bancar. Chiar si în corespondența sa privată cu Friedrich Engels și alți camarazi de idei, Marx nu ezita să utilizeze „argumente” de acest gen, dacă despre argumente vorbim.

Anticapitalismul, antiliberalismul și antisemitismul unesc cele două extreme (nu doar ele, dar în primul rând ele). Crimele în masă ale secolului XX s-au produs în numele acestor trei „anti”. Exemplele abundă. Noile populisme apelează la vechile clișee etnocentrice și xenofobe, nu pregetă să exploateze, cinic și manipulativ, temeri, fobii și resentimente individuale și colective. Extremismul funcționează ca un alfabet: spui a, urmează b, și c, și d, etc.

 

Text transmis la postul de radio Europa Libera.


Death in Teruel

01/05/2017

Spanish Civil War, Teruel, December 1937: One of the most famous and still controversial pics in the history of photojournalism. Robert Capa’s iconic “Republican soldier dead while trying to pull a telephone cable.” It came out first in January 1938 in the French magazine “Regard.”

 

Image may contain: one or more people, tree, plant and outdoor


May 1: The Dreams Betrayed…

01/05/2017

On May 1, thinking of the Spanish Civil War, the Stalinist confiscation of the internationalist dream, the liquidation of POUM, George Orwell’s “Homage to Catalonia”. The Spanish tragedy was both a civil war (lost by the loyalists and won by the Fascists supported by Hitler and Mussolini) ) and a libertarian revolution (strangled by the Stalinists)…

 

Image may contain: 1 person

Image: POUM poster, World War II Museum, Gdansk


Moral clarity: Macron in Oradour

28/04/2017

The battle for memory, the battle against historical revisionism, the battle against Holocaust negationists, the battle for dignity against infamy, the battle for liberal values against tribalistic xenophobia, Emmanuel Macron in the martyr-village Oradour-sur-Glane, Friday, April 28, 2017…

 

Image may contain: 4 people, flower, plant and outdoor


Vindictive, resentful, toxic

27/04/2017
Viktor Mihály Orbán’s attack on George Soros (“the speculator”) reminds me of the Nazi paranoid propagandist Julius Streicher. It has all the despicable ingredients of the worst anti-Semitic conspiracy theory, little man versus giant predator, honest versus dishonest, blood versus gold. I could call him Wagnerian Viktor… 🙂 “We are not as big and powerful as you are and as big and powerful as George Soros, the American financial speculator attacking Hungary, who has destroyed the lives of millions of Europeans with his financial speculations, who has been fined for speculation in Hungary, and who is an open enemy of the euro.” So, Viktor Orban, Soros is a murderer, a destroyer of millions of life. This is not mere populism, my friends, this is blunt, unabashed Fascism. Is he going to say next that Soros is also guilty of “ritual murder”? Do not expect Orbán to back off. He he will push further forward (sic!) in a most despicable and dangerous direction. This is what I call the alphabet of hatred: once one says “A”, the road to “Z” is there, inevitable, inescapable, inexorable. This is Viktor Mihály Orbán’s repugnant path…

On Italy’s Liberation Day

24/04/2017